Skip to main content

Redlines and Track Changes

Redlines help you see what changed in an editorial result without reading the whole manuscript from scratch.

They are mainly used in Editorial flows, where you want to compare the original writing against the edited result.

Bookcicle offers three redline types:

  • Auto: the recommended option for most people
  • Dom: best when document structure matters
  • Text: best when you want the cleanest reading view

You can also turn redlines off any time and read the clean result instead.

What Redlines Help You Do​

Redlines are useful when you want to:

  • spot wording changes quickly
  • review edits section by section
  • decide whether the new wording still sounds like you
  • compare a clean version with a marked-up version before downloading

If you only want to read the updated manuscript, you can leave redlines off and use the clean view.

Where You See Redlines​

In Editorial, redlines show up in the section viewer and in certain downloads.

That means you can:

  • review changes on screen
  • switch between a cleaner view and a marked-up view
  • download files meant for final reading or review

Redline Types​

Auto​

Auto is the best choice for most authors.

It tries to show the most readable version of the changes for each section. If one view looks messy or confusing, Auto can favor a clearer one.

Use Auto when:

  • you want the default setting
  • you do not want to think about diff style
  • you want the easiest review experience

Dom​

Dom is helpful when the shape of the document matters, not just the words.

This is often useful for material with:

  • headings
  • lists
  • stronger formatting patterns
  • more structured layouts

Use Dom when:

  • structure is part of what you are reviewing
  • you want changes aligned to the document layout
  • Auto is not giving you the view you want

Text​

Text focuses on the writing itself.

It is usually the easiest option when a redline looks too busy or too dramatic. If a section looks like everything changed even though only a few lines were edited, Text often gives a calmer view.

Use Text when:

  • you mainly care about the wording
  • the redline feels noisy
  • you want a simpler reading experience

Track Changes​

Track changes is part of the unified redline flow in Editorial.

When it is turned on, you can review edits more actively instead of only looking at a marked-up result.

You will see controls such as:

  • Review changes
  • Show raw redline
  • Reset review

This gives you two ways to work:

  • raw redline view for fast scanning
  • review mode for working through tracked changes section by section

When you accept or reject changes in that review flow, those decisions are kept locally in your browser for that section. That makes it easier to continue reviewing without losing your place.

If you need to start over for a section, Reset review clears that local review state.

Track changes is best when:

  • you want a more deliberate review pass
  • you are deciding change by change
  • you prefer a guided review instead of a full redline wall of markup

Downloads in Editorial​

Editorial downloads can include both clean and review-friendly options.

Common choices include:

  • Word downloads in clean or redline form
  • HTML and Markdown downloads in clean or commented form
  • PDF export for a clean reading copy

The exact download mix can vary by workflow, but Editorial is the main place where redline review is offered.

Tips​

  • Start with Auto unless you have a reason not to.
  • Switch to Text if a section looks too noisy.
  • Try Dom if structure matters as much as wording.
  • Turn on Track changes when you want a more guided review pass.
  • Download a clean file when you are ready to read without markup.

FAQs​

Do redlines exist for every service?

No. Redlines are mainly part of Editorial flows, where source-versus-result comparison is central to the experience.

Which redline type should I start with?

Start with Auto. It is the most user-friendly option for most manuscripts.

When should I use Track changes?

Use it when you want to review changes more carefully, one decision at a time, instead of only reading the raw redline.

Why does a redline sometimes look too big?

Sometimes formatting or structure changes make a section look more heavily edited than it really is. If that happens, switching to Text usually gives a cleaner reading view.

Can I still use clean output?

Yes. Redlines are optional. You can review the clean result or download a clean file whenever that is more useful.